On this page
Rule 7 lets the judge add documents to the case record — letters, records, exhibits, and sworn statements — so the court can decide your § 2255 motion with all the relevant facts. It can help you get evidence before the judge without a full hearing.
Section 2255 cases have many obstacles, but some rules help the person filing. Rule 7 of the Rules Governing Section 2255 Proceedings is one of them.
Outcomes vary. A past result does not predict or guarantee the outcome of any other case.
What does Rule 7 allow?
“If the motion is not dismissed, the judge may direct the parties to expand the record by submitting additional materials relating to the motion.” Rule 7(a). The judge can do this on a party’s request or on the judge’s own.
The materials can be broad: “letters predating the filing of the motion, documents, exhibits, and answers under oath to written interrogatories propounded by the judge. Affidavits also may be submitted and considered as part of the record.” Rule 7(b).
Why is Rule 7 useful?
It allows the court to consider materials that might not be admissible at a trial. Affidavits — written sworn statements — are hearsay, but they are common in the early stages of habeas cases. See, e.g., Abdur’Rahman v. Bell, 999 F.Supp. 1073, 1097 n. 30 (M.D. Tenn. 1998)(Rule 7 “contemplates a relaxed application of the hearsay, best evidence, authentication, and other evidentiary rules under the Federal Rules of Evidence.”).
The purpose is to help the court “clarify the relevant facts.” Vasquez v. Hillery, 474 U.S. 254, 258 (1986). In Vasquez, the Supreme Court approved a district court’s use of statistical analyses added to the record on a jury-discrimination claim. In short, you may be able to add documents that never made it into the criminal case record.
When can you use Rule 7?
After the motion survives the judge’s first review. You can ask early, to show the judge no hearing is needed. You can also ask closer to an evidentiary hearing. Courts have allowed expansion at different stages — early in the case, right before or during a hearing, and in connection with a motion for reconsideration or an appeal. See United States v. Kennedy, 225 F.3d 1187, 1191 (10th Cir. 2000).
How does the court handle Rule 7 materials?
File a motion to expand the record, attach the documents, and explain why they matter. The judge “must give the party against whom the additional materials are offered an opportunity to admit or deny their correctness.” Rule 7(c).
If the materials include affidavits, the other side has “the right to propound written interrogatories to the affiants, or to file answering affidavits.” 28 U.S.C. § 2246. When a fact turns on who is telling the truth, the court generally needs a hearing rather than dueling affidavits.
If the judge finds the documents relevant, the record will be expanded to include them. Even if the judge refuses, the request can still help you: the documents the court refused to add become part of the record on appeal. Schlup v. Delo, 513 U.S. 298, 308 n. 18 (1995). Make sure the request and the documents are filed on the docket.
Common questions
I have records that will help my § 2255 claim, but they are not in the record. How do I get them before the court?
File a motion to expand the record under Rule 7, with the documents attached. Rule 7 covers letters, affidavits, exhibits, and other documents.
Does the court have to accept the materials?
No. The decision is up to the judge. Explain how each document will help the court “clarify the relevant facts” of your claim. Expanding the record can matter a great deal, so take care with it. If you want help, book a consultation with Brandon Sample.
When can I use Rule 7?
After the motion survives the judge’s first review under Rule 4. People who think they can win without a hearing often ask early. You can also ask before or around an evidentiary hearing.
Related pages
Preparing for a Section 2255 Motion
Section 2255 Litigation: The Initial Motion
Section 2255 Litigation: Post-Filing Proceedings
Section 2255 Litigation: Amending the Motion
Section 2255 Litigation: Discovery
Section 2255 Litigation: The Evidentiary Hearing
Section 2255 Litigation: Resolution by Magistrate
Questions about your case? Book a consultation to talk it through with Brandon Sample.