A person who has finished a federal sentence cannot file a § 2255 motion, because 28 U.S.C. § 2255 is only for a person in custody. The remedy left is a writ of coram nobis, a rare court order that can undo a conviction after the sentence is over. On November 16, 2026, the Third Circuit held that Eduardo Cruz Mazzini waited too long to ask for one. In United States v. Cruz Mazzini, No. 26-2651 (Read the decision (PDF)), the court affirmed the denial of his petition, which came 13 years after he was removed from the United States.
The opinion is per curiam, meaning it is unsigned and issued for the whole panel. It says it is not binding precedent. Third Circuit I.O.P. 5.7.
The case before the petition
In 2010, Cruz Mazzini pleaded guilty in the District of Delaware to one count of making a false statement in a passport application. He was sentenced to time served and did not appeal. After immigration proceedings, he was removed to El Salvador in 2011. He later reentered the United States. In 2023, the court of appeals says, he was placed in deferred action until August 2027 after a U visa application was found to be bona fide, meaning genuine. The district court calls the U visa filing an application and, separately, says USCIS placed him in deferred action after finding the petition bona fide. Deferred action is a discretionary decision by the Department of Homeland Security to defer removal action, meaning to put off removal. 8 C.F.R. § 274a.12(c)(14); USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 3, Part C, Ch. 5. It is not a lawful immigration status, and it confers no status. USCIS, Frequently Asked Questions: What is deferred action?
In April 2024, he filed a petition for a writ of coram nobis. He said the government had induced his guilty plea by promising him an "S visa." He also said his lawyer gave ineffective assistance by advising him to plead guilty.
The district court denied the petition in a memorandum opinion dated April 17, 2025. It found that he had not given sound reasons for failing to seek relief earlier. He argued that he feared being detained and removed if he came forward. The court rejected that as a reason for the delay. It also noted that § 2255 relief was unavailable because he was no longer in federal custody on the 2010 conviction. The court later denied a motion for reconsideration and a request to clarify the record, and he appealed.
What the court decided
Federal courts issue coram nobis under the All Writs Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1651(a). The panel called it an extraordinary remedy issued in only limited situations. It listed the Third Circuit's five requirements:
- the person is no longer in custody;
- the person suffers continuing consequences from the conviction;
- there are sound reasons for not seeking relief earlier;
- there was no remedy at the time of trial; and
- the errors alleged are of a fundamental kind.
The panel drew that list from United States v. De Castro, 49 F.4th 836, 842 (3d Cir. 2022), which its opinion cites as Castro. De Castro says a petition must be denied if even one requirement is not met.
Only the third requirement was at issue. Cruz Mazzini argued that his fear of arrest, detention, and removal was a sound reason for waiting. The panel disagreed. It reasoned that he knew in 2011, when he was removed, that he had not received the immigration benefit he says he was promised for his plea. He did not seek coram nobis relief until 13 years later.
The panel compared the case to Ragbir v. United States, 950 F.3d 54 (3d Cir. 2020). There, a noncitizen spent more than six years pursuing administrative remedies in immigration proceedings before filing. The court held that was not a sound reason for the delay. Cruz Mazzini, the panel said, avoided immigration proceedings for 13 years and then asked the court to excuse the delay that built up during that time. Citing Ragbir, the panel said the timeliness standard for coram nobis does not forgive delay and dilatoriness, which means putting things off.
Because the delay decided the appeal, the panel did not rule on whether the plea was induced by a promise or whether his lawyer was ineffective.
He also challenged the district court's refusal to clarify whether he had falsely claimed to be a United States citizen under 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(6)(C)(ii). The panel said that issue was not before the district court, so it was not before the court of appeals.
What it means for a § 2255 motion
A § 2255 motion has a one-year deadline set by statute. Coram nobis has no fixed deadline in the Third Circuit, but that does not make it the easier path. De Castro says the court does not require a challenge at the earliest opportunity, yet it expects sound reasons for any wait. It also describes the sound-reason standard as stricter than the one used for § 2255 motions. In Cruz Mazzini, the panel counted the delay from 2011, when it said he knew he had not received the benefit he describes.
For a person still in prison or on supervised release, the practical point is that § 2255 is the remedy while custody lasts. Our guide to coram nobis and other writs explains what changes once the sentence is over. In this case, the district court looked at each period of waiting, including the years after he returned to the United States.
This note describes one unpublished opinion from one circuit. Other courts of appeals word the coram nobis test differently and can reach different results on other facts.
Source: United States v. Cruz Mazzini, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 26-2651. Read the order or opinion