How actual innocence claims work in a § 2255 motion

By Brandon Sample

On this page

In a federal 28 U.S.C. § 2255 motion, “actual innocence” means factual innocence: in light of all the evidence, it is more likely than not that no reasonable juror would have convicted. Bousley v. United States, 523 U.S. 614, 623 (1998). Courts use it mainly as a gateway past a procedural bar, not as a ground for relief by itself.

Key points.

  • Actual innocence means factual innocence, not a thin or legally insufficient case.
  • It usually works as a gateway. It lets a court hear a constitutional claim that a procedural rule would otherwise block. It is not a win by itself.
  • The Supreme Court has not decided whether innocence alone, with no other constitutional violation, is a ground for habeas relief.
  • The standard is demanding, and the Court has called tenable gateway pleas rare.
  • Deadline questions are covered in our guide to actual innocence and the one-year § 2255 deadline.

What does this page cover?

This page explains how a claim of innocence fits into a federal motion under 28 U.S.C. § 2255. It does not cover state-court exoneration procedures or state habeas petitions.

“Wrongful conviction” is an everyday phrase, not a term used in § 2255. The statute lists the grounds for a motion:

  • the sentence was imposed in violation of the Constitution or laws of the United States;
  • the court was without jurisdiction to impose the sentence;
  • the sentence was in excess of the maximum authorized by law; or
  • the sentence is otherwise subject to collateral attack.

28 U.S.C. § 2255(a). A person who believes a federal conviction was wrongful has to fit the claim into one of those grounds. Our pages on what a § 2255 motion can challenge and on filing the initial § 2255 motion explain the grounds and the filing itself.

What does “actual innocence” mean in a § 2255 case?

It means factual innocence. The person must show that, “in light of all the evidence,” it is “more likely than not that no reasonable juror would have convicted him.” Bousley, 523 U.S. at 623 (quoting Schlup v. Delo, 513 U.S. 298, 327-28 (1995)).

Bousley was a § 2255 case. The Supreme Court spelled out what the standard requires:

  • Factual innocence. “‘[A]ctual innocence’ means factual innocence, not mere legal insufficiency.” 523 U.S. at 623.
  • All the evidence. The government “is not limited to the existing record” and may present any admissible evidence of guilt, even evidence that was not offered before. Id. at 624.
  • Charges given up in a plea bargain. Where the government has forgone more serious charges in the course of plea bargaining, the showing of actual innocence “must also extend to those charges.” Id.
  • Reasonable jurors. The court makes “a probabilistic determination about what reasonable, properly instructed jurors would do.” Schlup, 513 U.S. at 329.

What is a gateway innocence claim?

A gateway claim uses innocence to get a court to hear a claim, not to decide it. If the showing is made, the court may reach a separate constitutional claim that a procedural rule would otherwise block.

The Supreme Court described this kind of innocence claim as “not itself a constitutional claim, but instead a gateway through which a habeas petitioner must pass to have his otherwise barred constitutional claim considered on the merits.” Schlup, 513 U.S. at 315 (quoting Herrera v. Collins, 506 U.S. 390, 404 (1993)). The table shows three procedural barriers and how innocence relates to each.

BarrierHow innocence relates to itSource
Procedural default (a claim not raised on direct appeal)The claim may be raised only if the person first shows “cause” and actual “prejudice,” or that he is “actually innocent.”Bousley, 523 U.S. at 622
The one-year deadlineActual innocence, if proved, serves as a gateway when the barrier is the expiration of the statute of limitations.McQuiggin v. Perkins, 569 U.S. 383, 386 (2013) (a state-prisoner case)
A second or successive motionThe statute sets its own test: newly discovered evidence that would establish by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable factfinder would have found the movant guilty of the offense.28 U.S.C. § 2255(h)(1)

What evidence does a gateway claim need?

It needs new, reliable evidence. A credible claim requires “new reliable evidence — whether it be exculpatory scientific evidence, trustworthy eyewitness accounts, or critical physical evidence — that was not presented at trial.” Schlup, 513 U.S. at 324.

The standard “is demanding and permits review only in the ‘extraordinary’ case,” but it “does not require absolute certainty about the petitioner’s guilt or innocence.” House v. Bell, 547 U.S. 518, 538 (2006). Schlup and House were state-prisoner cases. Bousley applied the Schlup standard in a § 2255 case.

Can innocence alone win a § 2255 motion?

The Supreme Court has not held that it can. A “freestanding” innocence claim asks for relief because the person is innocent, with no separate constitutional violation. The Court has left open whether such a claim exists. The table shows what it has said.

DecisionWhat the Court said
Herrera v. Collins, 506 U.S. 390 (1993)“Claims of actual innocence based on newly discovered evidence have never been held to state a ground for federal habeas relief absent an independent constitutional violation occurring in the underlying state criminal proceeding.” Id. at 400. The Court assumed, “for the sake of argument,” that a truly persuasive showing of innocence in a capital case would warrant federal habeas relief if there were no state avenue open to process such a claim, and said the threshold “would necessarily be extraordinarily high.” Id. at 417.
House v. Bell, 547 U.S. 518 (2006)The petitioner met the Schlup gateway standard. Asked to decide the question Herrera left open, the Court said, “We decline to resolve this issue.” It concluded that “whatever burden a hypothetical freestanding innocence claim would require, this petitioner has not satisfied it.” Id. at 554-55.
McQuiggin v. Perkins, 569 U.S. 383 (2013)“We have not resolved whether a prisoner may be entitled to habeas relief based on a freestanding claim of actual innocence.” Id. at 392.

All three were state-prisoner cases. None holds that a federal prisoner can get § 2255 relief on innocence alone. For a recent example of how one court of appeals handled a freestanding innocence argument in a § 2255 case, see our note on United States v. Cifuentes-Lopez.

Which § 2255 claims often go with an innocence argument?

Because innocence usually serves as a gateway, the motion also needs a claim that fits § 2255(a). In Schlup, the Court noted that the petitioner’s claim for relief depended on his Strickland and Brady claims, not on innocence by itself. 513 U.S. at 315.

Claims that are often paired with an innocence showing include:

  • Ineffective assistance of counsel. A claim that the defense lawyer’s performance fell below the Sixth Amendment standard and affected the result. See our guide to ineffective assistance claims under § 2255.
  • Withheld evidence. A claim that the prosecution did not turn over favorable evidence. See Brady violations.
  • Conduct the statute does not reach. In Bousley, the claim rested on a later Supreme Court decision that read the statute of conviction more narrowly. 523 U.S. at 616-18. See claims that a conviction violates federal law.

If the motion and the record leave important facts in dispute, the court may have to take evidence at an evidentiary hearing. The Rules Governing Section 2255 Proceedings set out how the case moves from filing to decision.

Can newly discovered evidence support a § 2255 motion?

It can matter in several ways. But new evidence of innocence is not, by itself, one of the grounds listed in § 2255(a). It has to connect to a claim the statute allows, or to a rule that lets the court reach that claim.

  • Timing. The one-year period can run from “the date on which the facts supporting the claim or claims presented could have been discovered through the exercise of due diligence.” 28 U.S.C. § 2255(f)(4). See newly discovered facts and due diligence.
  • A second motion. A second or successive motion based on new evidence must first be certified by a court of appeals under § 2255(h)(1). Our page on filing a second § 2255 motion covers that step.
  • The gateway. New reliable evidence is what a gateway innocence claim is built on. Schlup, 513 U.S. at 324.
  • A different motion. A motion for a new trial grounded on newly discovered evidence is a separate remedy. It must be filed within 3 years after the verdict or finding of guilty. Fed. R. Crim. P. 33(b)(1).

How does actual innocence affect the one-year deadline?

A § 2255 motion is subject to a one-year period of limitation. 28 U.S.C. § 2255(f). The Supreme Court has held that actual innocence, if proved, can serve as a gateway past an expired limitations period, and it cautioned that “tenable actual-innocence gateway pleas are rare.” McQuiggin, 569 U.S. at 386.

Delay still matters. “Unexplained delay in presenting new evidence bears on the determination whether the petitioner has made the requisite showing.” Id. at 399.

McQuiggin involved a state prisoner’s deadline under 28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1). How the exception applies to § 2255 motions, what evidence counts, and how the other deadline rules work are covered in our guide to the actual-innocence exception to the § 2255 deadline. Read that guide before relying on the exception.

What can a § 2255 motion not do?

A § 2255 motion is not a second appeal, and it does not reopen the question of guilt just because a person asks. The court decides whether one of the statutory grounds is met.

  • It is not an appeal. “[A] collateral challenge may not do service for an appeal.” United States v. Frady, 456 U.S. 152, 165 (1982). A claim that could have been raised on direct appeal may be procedurally defaulted.
  • It is not a retrial of the facts. In a state-prisoner case, the Supreme Court said federal habeas courts sit “to ensure that individuals are not imprisoned in violation of the Constitution — not to correct errors of fact.” Herrera, 506 U.S. at 400.
  • Relief is not automatic, and it takes different forms. If the court finds a ground for relief, it “shall vacate and set the judgment aside and shall discharge the prisoner or resentence him or grant a new trial or correct the sentence as may appear appropriate.” 28 U.S.C. § 2255(b).
  • It is not a declaration of innocence. An order granting a § 2255 motion rules on the grounds in the statute. The remedy may be a new trial or a new sentence.

Every case is different. A result in a past case doesn't necessarily mean success in another case.

Common questions

What is an actual-innocence claim in a § 2255 motion?

It is a showing that, in light of all the evidence, it is more likely than not that no reasonable juror would have convicted. Bousley v. United States, 523 U.S. 614, 623 (1998). In most cases it works as a gateway that lets the court hear a constitutional claim a procedural rule would otherwise block.

Is a wrongful-conviction claim the same as an appeal?

No. An appeal reviews errors in the trial court record. A § 2255 motion is a collateral challenge filed in the sentencing court, and it “may not do service for an appeal.” United States v. Frady, 456 U.S. 152, 165 (1982). The claim must fit one of the grounds in 28 U.S.C. § 2255(a).

Can newly discovered evidence support a 2255 motion?

It can, when it supports a claim § 2255 allows. New facts can also affect when the one-year period starts under § 2255(f)(4), and a second or successive motion based on new evidence must be certified by a court of appeals under § 2255(h)(1). New evidence of innocence alone has not been held to be a ground for federal habeas relief. Herrera v. Collins, 506 U.S. 390, 400 (1993).

Does actual innocence extend the time to file a 2255?

It can, within limits. The Supreme Court has held that actual innocence, if proved, can open a gateway past an expired limitations period, and it called such cases rare. McQuiggin v. Perkins, 569 U.S. 383, 386 (2013). Our guide to actual innocence under the one-year limit explains the details.

Official sources

Actual Innocence and the § 2255 Deadline

Section 2255 Litigation: The Initial Motion

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims

Second or Successive § 2255 Motions

Procedural Default

Questions about your case? Request a consultation to talk it through with Brandon Sample.

Request a consultation